
Who would’ve guessed an MTV guilty pleasure would become my summer obsession?
As the summer winds down and I look back at the last three sun soaked months there are a few things that happened right as planned, some that went slightly awry and others that I was totally wrong about. At the beginning of the summer, I raved about TNT’s “Dallas” reboot and proclaimed it my summer show. But, then something weird happened. While I still love “Dallas” and am reeling from the Finale shocker, another show eclipsed it in the race for my heart. After meeting Holland Roden and Colton Haynes from Teen Wolf when they rang the Nasdaq Bell I decided to give their show another shot. I watched the premiere and second episode after the MTV Movie Awards last year, but it did nothing for me. However, after they were so nice, so genuine and so passionate about their show I figured what’s the harm. Well the harm was that I became completely obsessed. I burned through the 12 episodes from season one in a matter of hours. Then I caught up on the season two episodes and then watched religiously every Monday.
The show is actually good, it’s not just summer TV good. Some people I know who watch a lot of supernatural themed TV shows claim it’s easily better than “Vampire Diaries” the CW’s biggest hit but I can’t comment on that as I’ve never seen it. Based on the Michael J. Fox film of the same name, the story centers on Scott McCall. A b-string lacrosse player and all around loser, until he gets bit by a werewolf and becomes a sports superstar. He has a girlfriend named Allison who’s family hunts werewolves, a best friend played by the delightful Dylan O’Brien and an anti-hero and occasional nemesis in Derek Hale. And, while the drama surrounding them and their classmates at school is awesome I would be lying if I said it was the only reason I watched. When I started my Netflix binge I read up and saw a lot of articles discussing the show’s proficiency for partial male nudity. I figured well that’s the gayest thing about this show. But, it turns out it’s not.

This scene right here made me realize their chemistry. It wasn’t until cast member Colton Haynes tweeted something about Sterek that I realized other people had this crazy idea.
Around episode 4, Dylan O’Brien’s character Stiles and Tyler Hoechlin’s Derek spend almost the entire episode together. Derek is injured and needs help which Stiles involuntarily gets stuck providing. At some point in the episode, the mix of Derek’s nastiness and Stiles’ snark created this amazing on-screen chemistry. Later in the season, Derek ends up living at Stiles’ house and there is a lot of pressing up against walls and stripping that takes place. So before I knew it they were my favorite couple on the show. Only they’re not actually a couple. Apparently, this doesn’t matter because I’ve discovered as a “Sterek Shipper” the internet is filled with people who root for couples that are not together in the world of their show. What makes this situation interesting, is that over the course of the season two run, the cast and creator of the show have all discussed the pairing of Stiles and Derek. It came up in interviews, twitter Q&As and a packed panel at Comic-Con. At the beginning they downplayed it, with Tyler Hoechlin claiming that people are seeing things but now he says it has a 50/50 shot of actually happening. With creator and developer Jeff Davis saying that it’s something he would consider.
So, now that leads to the inevitable question… is this a good idea? Neither of the two characters are openly gay, but neither have had an on-screen romance. One character has a crush on a redhead at school and the other used to sleep with the woman who went on to murder his entire family. Something that I admit could turn anyone off of women. I think my reservations stem from the idea that this isn’t something that comes from the writers, it’s not part of their grand plan and wasn’t ever discussed. And, I fear that if it does get written into the show it will be done in a sloppy and inorganic way just to keep the viewers happy. If you think that’s fine, you should check out this show called “Glee”. Ryan Murphy constantly gives into what the fans and press say, often mistakingly thinking if they loved it once they will love it again. For examples please refer to Kristen Chenoweth, Gwyneth Paltrow, the Journey songbook and the Michael Jackson tribute episode. I worry that if the writers decide to listen to the glaringly loud cry of the fans and make Stiles and Derek a couple that it won’t work. Because, it’s not something they created or saw, it’s something that the fans noticed.

This is a scene from the video the cast made to ask fans to vote for the Teen Choice Awards… which they eventually went on to win.
Now, that being said I think if it was done correctly it could be fantastic. Aside from the two actors having undeniable sexual chemistry, it would be a groundbreaking turn of events. While a lot of shows have had gay teens or straight teens realize they’re gay, no one has had two people realize it. Plus, even shows like “90210″ who accepted all the credit for making their womanizer Teddy come out as gay put him on the back burner as soon as the press died down. Plus, since these characters are already developed we don’t have to worry about them becoming cliches. Stiles reads comic books and plays sports, which gay teens do all the time. It would be nice to have a gay teen on television who isn’t wearing bow ties and singing Barbra Streisand songs between Spanish classes. I think two gay characters who don’t fit the teen show mold of what a gay teen is supposed be would be a welcome change. And, the evolution of this relationship from worst enemies to a sort of friendship then to a romantic relationship would not only be great TV but another amazing stride in the queerification of television. Now, there are a few set backs. Stiles jokingly came out to his father when he was caught sneaking into a gay club and Derek barked for someone to get Stiles away from him when they were injured a few episode ago. But, I feel these incidents can be explained away and if the writers are stumped they should consult the heaps of fan-fiction written about the two that litters the “Teen Wolf” tag on sites like Tumblr.
Season Three of “Teen Wolf” is currently in development so that is the point of this open letter. I won’t be mad if Stiles and Derek remain heterosexuals who are trapped in a bromance. But, I will be mad if their sexual chemistry and the desire for them to get together felt by me and countless others is exploited. They recently used the pair in their campaign for the Teen Choice Awards. And, in a recent episode the gay subtext was so heavy I was surprised one of the other characters didn’t trip over it. So essentially, if you’re not going to take this storyline on and deal with all of it’s complications then please don’t wave it in my face to keep me interested. That’s called Queer Bating, and it has the same effect on me that the full moons have on Scott.